Skip to main content

Speed comparsions between Plone and Wordpress

Jon Stahl wrote recently a blogpost about Plone being three times faster than Dropal, Joomla and Wordpress. We had a small discussion about this in my workplace and as my colleague pointed out this wasn't a really that comprehensive test that you could state Plone being 3 times faster than it's competitors. This seemed a bit unfair test considering how fast this has been spread in tweet/blogosphere, so I decided to repeat the test with a bit more critical viewpoint.

What's wrong in the original test? No one would consider opinion poll with 10 answers nowhere near trustworthy - it's all the same with requests. I didn't want to put up all the cms so I just set up second best (Wordpress 2.9.1) and compared that to my Plone development site (4.0a3). As a comparsion I did the first test with same ab command Jon used and my iMac gave following results:

Wordpress: 7.13 requests / second
Plone: 17.10 requests / second

So far we have clear winner and Jons data holds up... almost. Anyways.. to do a bit more realistic test I used 100 requests - first with no concurrency and then concurrency value set to 3 (ab -n 100 -c 3 http://...) Results are a bit different:

No concurrency, 100 requests
Wordpress: 7.18
Plone: 16.46

Concurrency 3, 100 requests
Wordpress: 13.04 requests/second
Plone: 16.50 request/second

To add some more requests I got just small differences anymore. With ab -n 200 -c 3:

Concurrency 3, 200 requests
Wordpress 13.09 req/s
Plone 16.37 req/s

Concurrency 4, 200 requests
Wordpress: 13.04 req/s
Plone 16.39 req/s

So when I just added some more requests situation was quite the same, but when we have (in the real world) that much requests in shortest time possible there are bound to be some concurrency. Adding concurrency to my test situation doesn't look that bad for Wordpress anymore.

Even though Wordpress did better job with more concurrency it still got beaten by Plone in my rough testing. Yet it's not that spectacular to be 1.2 times faster than being three times faster. And don't get me wrong - as a Plone developer and administrator I'm really thankful for all the people who have contributed to Plone tuning in one way or another. It's still good to be a bit critical before we claim that good results :)

To be clear, I'm not really familiar with Wordpress or anything which has something to do with PHP. As Jon I also put up MAMP environment and installed Wordpress there using PHP 5. There were no other customizations so I don't know how tuned it was for production use.  My Plone on the other hand is my development instance and it was running in debug mode on the foreground so it was in worst possible situation for Plone to run... or well.. I could have enabled very specific logging, but that would have been overkill for this test.

Popular posts from this blog

Plone 4, ZEO and supervisor

This post belongs also to the "lessons learned" category.

With Plone 3, ZEO and supervisor combination you've probably configured your supervisor to start plone instances by running $BUILDOUT/parts/client1/bin/runzope.

Problem is that with Plone 4 your $BUILDOUT/parts/client folder doesn't contain anything else than etc folder. You know starting instances by targeting supervisor to use $BUILDOUT/bin/client1 fg doesn't work like you'd expect (supervisor would control the client1 script - not the actual plone process).

My colleague Jussi Talaskivi figured that using 'console' argument instead of 'fg' for bin/client1 script should do the trick. With 'console' argument stopping, starting and restarting Plone 4 instances with supervisor works like a charm.

Below is full example of working supervisor configuration.

[buildout] parts = supervisor [supervisor] recipe = collective.recipe.supervisor port = 8200 user = xxxx password = xxxx pr…

Plone RPM deployment

It's been ages since I wrote my last post. I guess now it's time to make that up with post about Plone deployment. In a last few months I've had chance to invest part of my time at work to develop our Plone deployment model and since there hasn't been that many posts about the subject I thought I'd share my experiences for the community.

Before I get to the details here's some background information about the environment I've been dealing with. I'm working at the University of Jyväskylä, Finland. Our university is a heavy weight Plone adopter here in Finland. Plone is in use by every faculty and department. We have about 500 - 700 content managers and about 50 - 60 separate Plone instances. Our front page gets about 2 - 3 million hits page views / month. The important information in previous data is the amount of instances. 50 - 60 is just my estimation about our current status and that amount is increasing every year. I'm sure you got the idea so I&…